Moving from Distracted to Discerning Minds

by Joan Lange on November 21, 2014


Screen Shot 2014-11-20 at 6.30.26 PM

“If you could control someone’s attention, what would you do with it?” Sleight-of-hand artist Apollo Robbins poses this question in a TED talk “The Art of Misdirection.”  In Robbins’ amusing stage demonstration, he “pickpockets” items from a willing volunteer by using a series of verbal cues and distracting hand manipulations to misdirect attention. In the act’s finale, even the audience becomes surprised by their inattention, failing to perceive what was right before their eyes. Though not in the business of fleecing young teens, educators are in a similar struggle to find ways to engage adolescents’ attention and promote learning and memory.

Researcher and author Maggie Jackson picks up this theme in her book Distracted.  Jackson cites a perception experiment that was done in 1999 in which research subjects were asked to view a video and count the number of times a basketball was passed among players wearing white shirts.  The viewers were so intent on watching the passed ball that they missed seeing a costumed gorilla that walked among the ball handlers (Jackson 138).  You have to see this video to believe it: Gorillas in Our Midst. The research study suggests that “Without attention, we often do not see unanticipated events, and even with attention, we cannot encode and retain all the details of what we see” (Simmons and Chabris 1065). Interestingly, these findings dramatically point out several concerns relevant to our “distracted” age of technology: 1) Are student information seekers open to those “unanticipated events,” those moments of discovery? and 2) How much are students attending to the information they read?

As one approach to addressing these concerns, I would like to suggest a movement away from distraction and toward more discerning minds by engaging students in directed physical movement as they think and attend to information.  For several years I have incorporated student discussion activities suggested by Barry Gilmore in his book Speaking Volumes; here are a few movement/discussion activities that have been successful in getting students on their feet, tuning in their attention, and developing insightful class discussions. (The following examples are from discussion prompts I adapted, but Gilmore has generously provided a series of discussion resources linked to novels and nonfiction books on his wiki.  Be sure to check these out.)

Survey Lines

Students take a pencil and paper survey, total their responses, and then line up in order of their total.  The strategy to compiling this survey is to make the survey statements from one extreme point of view.  Students then take turns discussing their rationale for giving a statement a high or low agreement rating.  This activity gets everyone talking and anticipating themes or ideas that will be later read in a text.  I used this activity with a Freshman Health class unit on Digital Citizenship, and the Bullying Survey led to a good discussion of the myths of bullies/victims.  Sample survey statements included:

1.  Kids bounce back quickly after being bullied.                          5       4       3      2      1

2.  Victims of bullying often bring it upon themselves.               5       4       3      2      1

3.  Bullying will disappear if you ignore it.                                    5       4       3      2      1

(*Myths of Bullying Statements adapted from 2011 Centerstone presentation on bullying, at Pope John Paul II High School.  See more information about Centerstone.)


How just are endings to characters’ dilemmas in stories?  This grid is a fun way to explore poetic justice.  Use masking tape to mark out a large grid on your classroom floor and write the following in each square of the grid:

Larger Grid

As you name a character from a story, students stand in the grid representing their assessment of the character’s ending and  then discuss their rationale. Using examples from the book Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier, students might stand in the “End Badly, Gets what he/she deserves” for the sinister character Mrs. Danvers. However, students may have more ambivalence as they discuss the character Mrs. DeWinter…did she end well and get what she deserved or did she end badly and get/not get what she deserved? (How happy is a life living in hotels with the moody Mr. DeWinter, someone who murdered his first wife?)

Fishbowl Discussions

As the name suggests, a circle of three to four chairs forms an inner circle as the rest of the class stand outside.  Only students seated in the circle can speak to a prompt; students in the outlying areas can tap in to take a seat and continue the discussion.  An interesting aspect of fishbowl discussions is that students waiting to speak must also “listen/learn” from those in the circle who are speaking so that when their turn to tap in happens, the new arrivals have relevant, perceptive comments to add to or challenge what was previously stated.

Possible Fishbowl discussion prompts:

1) How much of a willing participant were Hitler youth members and/or German citizens during WWII?  (for a discussion of books such as Hitler Youth, The Book Thief, or All the Light We Cannot See)

2) How can we sort out truth or justice in criminal cases that involve bias toward gender, race, or social status? (for a discussion of books such as To Kill a Mockingbird or Alias Grace)

In closing, consider again, “If you could control someone’s attention, what would you do with it?”  Join the movement to focus student attention and deepen learning!


Citation Theory – A recap

November 19, 2014

Thanks for all for your help last week as I prepared a block class on citation theory for our three AP Language classes. It was surprisingly the most fun that I have had with a class all year because it wasn’t just a crunch of time to answer panicked questions about individual sources. I think […]

Read the full article →

Red light, green light

November 18, 2014

I’m actually so swamped it was hard for me to find time to compose this blog post, and my calendar reminds me I’m late with it, too. I’m sure everyone knows the words to that song, but nonetheless it’s true, and I think particularly so for solo librarians to whom all responsibilities fall. (And no […]

Read the full article →

Library & Capstone, like PB&J

November 17, 2014

The Capstone Project, loosely defined as an independent project, typically completed during junior or senior year, allowing a student to complete an in depth study or exploration of something that is meaningful to them that either isn’t included in the school’s curriculum or that allows exploration at a much deeper level. They research it, reflect […]

Read the full article →

to sell is librarianship …

November 12, 2014

creative commons licensed ( BY-NC-SA ) flickr photo shared by Simon Greig Photo A few weeks ago a post in the Chronicle of Higher Education, “Surprising Gadgets, Not Just Books Are Ready for Checkout at College Libraries,” made the rounds on my Twitter feed. Comments from folk in my PLN ranged from the slightly snarky, “Really? […]

Read the full article →

Literacy Apps in the Library

November 7, 2014

This summer I read Jason Boog’s Born Reading: Bringing up Bookworms in a Digital Age – From Picture Books to eBooks and Everything in Between. I have a strong interest in how our students read electronically and a passion for integrating new literacy platforms in my classroom. Through a series of anecdotes about raising a […]

Read the full article →

Private Libraries

November 5, 2014

Private Libraries My husband tore a page out of Fortune magazine and thrust it into my hands, “You need to read this!”  The article, Archive of Wonder, is about Jay Walker, the founder of Priceline, and the library he assembled in his Connecticut home.  Mr. Walker’s private library contains a range of artifacts from the […]

Read the full article →

Ebola! Ebola! Ebola!

October 22, 2014

Not too long ago I came upon a blog posting on Washington Post’s The Intersect by Caitlin Dewey (October 2, 2014) with the catchy title/subtitle “Popular on Amazon: Wildly Misleading Self-Published Books On Ebola By Random People Without Medical Degrees” and it prompted me to look into the world of publisher credibility. A (young) teaching colleague […]

Read the full article →

The Ghosts of Students Past

October 19, 2014

So here’s a thing that has happened on several occasions over the last few months: alumni, now enrolled in college, getting in touch to ask for library services from me. I’m of two minds on this, and I think you’ll all see where I’m going here . . . one part of me is worried […]

Read the full article →

Ode to a Quiet Morning

October 15, 2014

I’m sitting in a Calculus classroom a building and a floor away from the library as I proctor the PSAT for my advisees. Last week was Homecoming/Spirit week, and this two and a half hours of silence sitting in one space feels so luxurious. With routine library duties and beginning to teach research “boot camp” […]

Read the full article →